Confirmed: Power Girl is the Supergirl of Earth 2

Kevin Maguire’s early, rough sketch of Earth 2′s Supergirl, based on the Earth 2′s Superman costume (Maguire did not intend this for public viewing and was surprised when DC published it on The Source)

Remember what I said about this costume (as rendered by George Perez on Worlds’ Finest#1) being perfect if it had pants? Yeah. No pants for Supergirl on any Earth, apparently. Huh.

“Superman’s cousin loves her adopted world with a passion, seeing how the people of Earth have adopted her and taken her to their hearts,” said EARTH 2 writer James Robinson. “She is the definitely brightest light among this first group of Earth 2 heroes.”

“Meet the Earth 2 Supergirl, aka Karen Starr,” said WORLDS’ FINEST editor Wil Moss. “As readers of MISTER TERRIFIC already know, Karen has been busy since she arrived on the main DCU Earth, creating a successful company and dating the brilliant Michael Holt. But what are her true motives behind those actions? How did she get here? And what incident prompts her to take up her new identity of Power Girl? Find out in WORLDS’ FINEST #1!”

Earth 2 Character Designs — Supergirl

So Power Girl isn’t Power Girl, she’s pre-Crisis Supergirl. What the frick? The whole concept of Power Girl is that she’s not Supergirl. HOW DO YOU SCREW THAT UP?

In this universe something tragic happened that caused Kara to cut her hair, change her outfit and beginning calling herself Power Girl on Earth 1. We know it was something grim and tragic because she’s described as the “brightest light among this first group of Earth 2 heroes” and the descriptions for Earth 2′s big three has been a parade of tragedy:

What made Power Girl unique as a person is gone. In the Bronze Age, Power Girl’s rough-and-tumble, super confident personality wasn’t a result of anything bad happening to her. That was just the way Supergirl turned out on the Golden Age-esque Earth 2. And that was cool (even if the way Paul Levitz wrote her often came across as a stereotypically cliched male impression of feminism). That Power Girl no longer exists in this new universe. “Power Girl” is now just a new identity that an alternate Supergirl takes on. That makes me incredibly sad.

I can’t even begin to articulate how angry I am at DC’s wholesale destruction of Earth 2. It’s like DC’s showrunners ran through a checklist of stupid cliches of How To Give Your Characters Maximum Angst and patted themselves on the back for their Bold! Fresh! Hip! approach, when all they did was crib from Women in Refrigerators. Lois Lane: dead. The Amazon nation: dead. Selena Kyle: dead. These are not groundbreaking ideas guys! Read a freakin’ Elseworlds, or any run from Wonder Woman EVER. Killing off popular, viable female characters to give male characters an excuse to be dicks and make Wonder Woman an angry, alienated caricature is not cool or interesting or new. It’s old and boring. And it makes me not care about Superman or Batman or Wonder Woman. It takes some serious effort to make THOSE characters unpalatable.

Like most people I’d hoped that Earth 2 would be a refuge from the awfulness of the New 52. Now we know better. Didio and Lee never had any intention of honoring the heroic, hopeful spirit of previous DC eras.

George Perez and Kevin Maguire on Power Girl’s costume redesign

Black and white headshot sketch of Huntress and Power Girl by George Perez

(I am amused by how Power Girl looks like Trixie Belden in this sketch. I loved those books growing up :)

George Perez, via Facebook:

Hey all, with the color cover of WORLD’S FINEST finally released in the solicitations, I just wanted to say something that I’ve already stated in reply to another post. I had nothing to do with the designs of any of the costumes here, with the exception of some minor tweaks to the seams in Power Girl’s costume. (Also, the color shown is not the final version since there are some corrections that need to be made before the book’s actual publication.

- George Perez, Facebook Fan Page, Feb 10, 2012

I just wanted to give a shout out to my friends JC Marie and Margie Vizcarra Cox for being my cover girl models for the new WORLD’S FINEST #1. I couldn’t have asked for two more delightful muses!

George Perez, Facebook Fan Page, Feb 10, 2012

More regarding George’s models for Power Girl and Huntress:

Just finished the cover for WORLD’S FINEST #1, which is now being colored. Since I can’t show the cover until DC releases the image, here are some rough character studies [link to image on Facebook] showing the two lovely young ladies I’ve asked to be my inspiration for the likenesses of Huntress and Power Girl. The Huntress is inspired by my dear friend and cosplayer supreme Margie Cox and Power Girl is based on another friend named Jana who models professionally under the name JC Marie. I am grateful that they both agreed to do this and I hope I will do them justice in the series. — with Margie Vizcarra Cox.

- George Perez, Facebook Fan Page, Feb 4, 2012

I googled JC Marie and Margie Cox and, well. I believe the euphemistic industry term regarding what JC Marie does is “glamour model”. Or in the real world, “softcore porn photography”. About that pandering to the male gaze problem that superhero comics have? Yeah…

Kevin Maguire, via Twitter:

@akosiJepoii: Is that really Power Girl’s new costume? Please say Nooooo

@maguirekevin: My understanding is it’s still going to be tinkered with, but, yeah. Sorry.
- Twitter, Feb 12/12

@maguirekevin: Lots of folks hate the new Power Girl costume and I get it. Had I free reign, I’d have done it different… - Twitter, Feb 12, 2012

@maguirekevin: …but I hope people will judge the book more on how she’s played rather than how she’s dressed. - Twitter, Feb 12, 2012

@dcwomenkicknass: Who designed the new Power Girl costume, Cully or Jim?

@maguirekevin: Me. Within parameters, pants, cape, no boob window, no sleeves. I wanted it to look “connected” to the Earth-2 Superman design
- Twitter, Feb 12, 2012

@impoliteopinion: no, @scottmarshall, @maguirekevin did away with an iconic look in order to give her a terrible look reminiscent of the early 80s.

@maguirekevin: @impoliteopinion @scottmarshall Your anger,however, is mis-directed. I didn’t decide how she should look. I gave them more than one design
- Twitter, Feb 14, 2012

Hat tips to Laura M., Sue and the commenters at DC Women Kicking Ass

First Look at Power Girl’s New 52 Costume

DC has released the cover of Worlds’ Finest #1 by George Perez, which answers the question of whether Power Girl will be getting a new costume.

Power Girl and Earth-2 Huntress leaping through a portal, backed by an alternative universe Supergirl and Robin

Power Girl and Huntress jumping through a portal…but who are that alt-universe Supergirl and fem-Robin behind them? Cover identities they’ve used on another world, or their true identities on Earth Two? What’s going on?!

I like the mysterious alt-universe Supergirl’s costume a lot more than Power Girl’s new duds. That Supergirl looks amazing. The alt-universe Robin (Helena?!) is, uh, interesting. But Power Girl? Meh. My reaction is lukewarm.

What I like: the white unitard with the high collar and seaming details. Love it. That’s Power Girl. I’m very happy they ditched the boob window.

What I dislike: 1) The super-esque shield, with the attempt to integrate a stylized “P”, in Superman and Supergirl’s colours. Power Girl doesn’t do chest symbols. 2) The gold gloves and boots. I have no strong opinion on their design, what I don’t like is that they’re gold instead of blue. Those aren’t Power Girl’s colours.

This outfit doesn’t shout “Power Girl” to me. There’s nothing to tie everything together into one cohesive, iconic design. It’s not a bad costume; it’s just not her. (It’s basically a better version of Supreme‘s costume.)

They’re on the right track with the white leotard. They got that part right from Joel Carroll’s great Power Girl redesign:

Power Girl redesign featuring blue, pirate-style, over the knee boots, white unitard, blue gloves, and red cape attached with a shoulder shield

Substitute Amanda Conner’s awesome bright blue zippered gloves and matching boots for the thigh-high boots and pirate-style cuffs, and this is the look DC should have gone with in creating a slick, non-boob focused update for Power Girl.

What really interests me on this cover is that amazing alt-universe Supergirl costume: who’s that? Can we have that costume for Earth-1?! If she’s wearing pants, I’m sold. Love the gloves! But does this mean that Power Girl actually Supergirl on her own world? Please no! That would destroy the integrity of the character, whose defining feature has always been that she’s not Supergirl. I also really hope that Helena Wayne is not actually Robin on Earth-2. That would make the Huntress…her dad’s sidekick? Oh no :( I really hate the idea of Power Girl being just Supergirl and Huntress being a Robin on another planet.

So many questions.

WORLDS’ FINEST #1
Written by PAUL LEVITZ
Art by GEORGE PEREZ, SCOTT KOBLISH and KEVIN MAGUIRE
Cover by GEORGE PEREZ
1:25 Variant cover by KEVIN MAGUIRE
On sale MAY 2 · 32 pg, FC, $2.99 US · RATED T
• New ongoing series featuring POWER GIRL and HUNTRESS of Earth 2!
• PAUL LEVITZ teams with amazing artists GEORGE PEREZ and KEVIN MAGUIRE.
• Discover why these two heroes are stranded on our Earth – and what it means for the heroes of the DC Universe.

Here is the variant cover to Earth Two #1 also shipping in May. Those are some truly terrible costumes.

an alternative world Superman, Wonder Woman and Batman in battle

EARTH TWO #1
Written by JAMES ROBINSON
Art by NICOLA SCOTT and TREVOR SCOTT
Cover by GREG CAPULLO
1:25 Variant cover by IVAN REIS and JOE PRADO
On sale MAY 2 • 40 pg, FC, $3.99 US • RATED T
• First issue of an ongoing series from writer JAMES ROBINSON and artist NICOLA SCOTT!
• Who are the heroes of EARTH 2 – and what befell them?
• Starring ALAN SCOTT, JAY GARRICK and many others!
• You may think you know Earth 2…but this is DC Comics – The New 52, where anything can happen!
• Don’t miss the extra-sized debut issue!

Ironically the copy promotes the JSA’s Alan Scott and Jay Garrick, but the cover shows the JLA trinity. Hopefully the regular cover shows the actual JSA members from, you know, Earth 2.

Power Girl to star in “Worlds’ Finest” in May 2012

In May of 2012, DC Comics will release a “Second Wave” of titles as part of its historic DC COMICS-THE NEW 52 initiative.

DC COMICS-THE NEW 52 “Second Wave” includes:

EARTH 2 – Writer: James Robinson. Artist: Nicola Scott. The greatest heroes on a parallel Earth, the Justice Society combats threats that will set them on a collision course with other worlds.

WORLDS’ FINEST – Writer: Paul Levitz. Artists: George Perez and Kevin Maguire. Stranded on our world from a parallel reality, Huntress and Power Girl struggle to find their way back to Earth 2. Perez and Maguire will be the artists on alternating story arcs.

- DCU The Source: Introducing the “Second Wave” of DC Comics-The New 52

Last week, we announced DC COMICS-THE NEW 52 “Second Wave,” featuring six new series coming in May. In WORLDS’ FINEST, writer Paul Levitz jumps between parallel Earths, following the story of Earth 2’s Huntress and Power Girl as they struggle to find their way back home. But fans of these heroes should keep in mind that they aren’t the Huntress and Power Girl we know so well. Levitz offers some insider insights on what readers can – and can’t – expect from WORLDS’ FINEST:

“Nothing’s quite the same…the world they’re in, the rules of the game, the stakes…so Helena and Kara are facing dilemmas in WORLDS’ FINEST that are nothing like any version of either of their previous lives…

Learn the identities they used on Earth 2…watch why those change when they get here…and see the choices they face. It’s a layered puzzle, pulling on the rich history of the DC Universe…but even more on the potential for an explosively different lives in the New 52 universe…and over time, it’ll all pull together to affect the lives of so many…

As a writer, it’s a true joy to collaborate with star artists George Perez and Kevin Maguire, and to be able to design a series to fit their talents together as seamlessly as possible. And the heroines of WORLDS FINEST are simultaneously old friends (to me, as well as each other) and very new acquaintances that you want to grow closer to…if you can. They’re showing a lot of their true selves…but hiding even more.

Welcome to new worlds…and a totally new WORLDS’ FINEST.”

- DCU The Source: Writer Paul Levitz on World’s Finest

Paul Levitz spoke to Newsarama about revisiting Power Girl and Huntress in the new universe. A few items that jumped out at me:

[Worlds' Finest] will bridge the gap between the “New 52″ Earth and DC’s new version of Earth 2, bringing Power Girl and Huntress from one parallel world to another.

The story ties into the new Earth 2 title by James Robinson and Nicola Scott, which launches at the same time as Worlds’ Finest. It also stars the same character as Levitz’s Huntress mini-series.

Fans can’t help wondering…. is this the same Karen Starr who showed up in Mr. Terrific?

Was this Earth 2 Huntress the daughter of Bruce Wayne and Selina Kyle on Earth 2?

And if she was, will she meet this Earth’s Bruce Wayne in person?

We learn from Levitz that the Helena who currently appearing in his Huntress mini is not Helena Bertinelli as was implied, but actually Helena Wayne from a parallel Earth. Which is cool if she’s impersonating Earth 1′s Huntress and Bertinelli does in fact exist in the New 52, but enormously disappointing otherwise. With DC’s “no duplicates” (except for all these duplicates here and here…) rule in place, I fear the rich, complex Huntress character we’ve known for the past 22 years is, like, Oracle, no more. DC Comics: always burning bridges.

Levitz: [...] I think we got a great response to the Huntress mini-series, and I think that response was the attitude that she portrayed in those stories, and I’m hoping to be able to do that kind of level of reaction going forward.

The first scene in the first issue is basically kind of a Sex in the City moment of the two girls at lunch, at a posh place that turns out to be in Tokyo, and Helena’s busy burning her Helena Bertinelli passport and playing with a deck of five or six other passports she’s got in other names, trying to decide who she’s going to be next.

Newsarama: That name Bertinelli in there is a fun tease, but this is Helena Wayne, right?

Levitz: We will ultimately know that she’s Helena Wayne of Earth 2, but whether Bruce will know that she’s Helena Wayne, or how Bruce or Selina Kyle will come to know that and react to that, we’ll see. I’m still working out all the dramatic potential in it. Obviously, there’s enormous pent up possibility in those moments, and you want to make all that drama work. And you don’t want to do all that in issue #1, panel #1. You want to take people on an interesting ride.

It’s going to be very connected both to Earth 2 and to the New 52 Earth. In a sense, it’s the bridge book between the two. It should be a very rich, exciting experience, if we do it right.

Newsarama: Will they encounter people from Earth 2, or are they the only ones here from Earth 2?

Levitz: As far as I know, they’re the only ones here from Earth 2 so far.

Newsarama: But they do tie into what James [Robinson] is writing in the Earth 2 series?

Levitz: Oh, absolutely. They’re here because of what happens in his book. And they’re concerned in their different ways very much about what’s going on on the world they came from. Maybe Power Girl is more concerned about that part than Huntress. But each has their set of issues back there.

Newsarama: We’ve seen Karen Starr in Mr. Terrific, but only briefly. Is she like the Power Girl we’ve know in the past, before the relaunch?

Levitz: I think she’ll be a little bit different from what you’ve seen in the past. I’m building off the facts that are established about her in Mr. Terrific. I’m trying to pick up on things that happened in those issues and connect them in properly. But there’s a lot more to her story.

She’s got a very defined sense of mission about going home. She needs to get back there. She feels that world needs her there. And hopefully that will play out in a very interesting fashion.

These two gals got dumped here in a confusing and challenging circumstance, in a world that’s a lot like theirs, but not the same. And each of them has different sets of things they want to do as a result.

Karen Starr’s brief appearance in Mr. Terrific is best forgotten. Nice diplomatic answer from Levitz on that subject.

- Newsarama: Paul Levitz Explains More About WORLDS’ FINEST, EARTH 2

I honestly didn’t think we’d ever see Power Girl again. This “new” universe is shaping up to be an awful lot like the “old” pre-Crisis universe with a lot of highly selective cherry-picking from the post-Crisis era.

As I periodically check in to see how the New 52 is developing, I continue to be disappointed at seeing the same old names tasked with modernizing DC’s universe. It doesn’t excite me to try DC’s “new improved” universe when they keep going back to the same heavily used creative pool. (My god, Paul Levitz wrote Huntress and Power Girl in the 1970s. George Perez and Kevin Maguire were hot artists in the 1980s. Personally I like Maguire’s art a lot and think it holds up well today; on the other hand, Perez’ art always feels a bit dated and awkwardly out of place on current books. The writer concerns me more: couldn’t they find someone younger who could actually relate to twenty-something women in the 2010s? Someone with better references than “Sex & the City”?!)

Are you excited about Power Girl being included in the New 52? It does make things enormously simpler for her to be a universe-hopper from another parallel world who’s stuck on “our” world with her Huntress. I wouldn’t mind Power Girl being a less tragic character than the one who suffered through all that post-Crisis bullshit.

Can they really go back to pre-Crisis characters if it means burning beloved characters who bear the same name? Are creators who were around during the last reboot the right team to make those characters relevant for today? How likely is it that Levitz, Perez, and Maguire will even be working on the book six months from now?

More importantly: what will the costumes look like?

Comics Alliance wins the Best Title Award for their reaction to the news: DC Reboots the Huntress So Hard that Her Reboot Got Rebooted