REVIEW by Mark Matharu 5th August 2000, 8.30 am London
time a parcel flopped through the letterbox onto the mat.
What's this? I am not expecting anything until the 12th. it
cannot be the Supergirl Limited Edition DVD as that isn't released until Tuesday 8th. But
sure enough it was.
SUPERGIRL LIMITED EDITION DVD. it even has a number on the
back of the case which is quite thick and sturdy. 3 days early and all it cost was twenty
quid. From Admit One well done guys.
I ripped off the cardboard packaging cut away the cellophane
shrink wrap and opened the box. Two discs and an unusually thick booklet. In goes the
first disc. Film in widescreen. The sound coming from the speakers was sharp and the
colours were bright.
The film itself was like the version that was on television
at Easter but in widescreen and surround sound. Somehow there was still something missing
at the beginning you do not see the girl solving the maths equation and you don't see
Jimmy and Lucy bidding farewell to Ethan at the end, but there it was on disc two.
All the extras was very good the German trailer sounded like
a cheap porno movie. It was good seeing the making of Supergirl as we didn't get this
shown in England as I recall but I was only 14 and didn't watch much tele. So Jeannot and
Scott have voices now I know what they sound like.
This DVD is brilliant well worth the money if not more. Only
one more thing to say. ROLL ON SUPERMAN DVD
REVIEW by DIESEL
8th August
Rather than elaborate on the details of the Limited Edition
disc {which is information that will probably be discussed at length in other reviews), I
would like to point out that for those of us who have long viewed SUPERGIRL on tape or
disc, the DVD is a slightly different viewing experience...and a slightly disconcerting
one at that. Although the movie is in the widescreen format at a 2.35:1 ratio, there is a
good deal of picture information originally seen in the full frame version that has been
cropped for the 2.35:1 transfer. Throughout the movie, I kept remarking to my significant
other (who hated the film and groaned every time a bad line of dialogue was spoken --- and
there are a lot of those), "the bottom of the movie looks cramped!" Sure enough,
a comparison with the original pan and scan tape proves me correct.
In short, although we see more of the movie on the sides, we
see less of it on the bottom and top. Since the last time I saw the movie in widescreen
was back in college at the movie theaters, I cannot recall or confirm whether the DVD
reflects the true theater ratio, but for some reason, I think (and I could be dead wrong)
that they cropped too much of the picture vertically.
Just take a look at the TV spot trailers, especially where
Kara tells Ethan "I'm his cousin." You can see more of the "S" on her
costume than in the widescreen movie where it is virtually cut-off.. I now wish that the
DVD had a full screen option in addition to the letterboxed version of the movie. In
comparison to the unmatted version, some of the scenes in the widescreen look too cramped.
On the other hand, the overall picture looks great, and
Ms.Slater looks drop-dead gorgeous. SUPERGIRL has never been in better shape.
REVIEW by AHEM
15th August
To begin, this film is a
vehicle for one of Britain's most overlooked cinematographers, Alan Hume BSC. Finally we
have on DVD his greatest achievement. Shania Twain, eat your heart out.
Technically, this film looks like superior to any film made
around the 1984 period, and it seems a crime that it received no academy award for visual
effects, considering the winner for that year was Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom
with its shoddy mine car racing. Indeed, a friend of mine viewed this with me on a 16:9
TV, the best money can get in 5.1 too, and he demanded that he scan through all of the
wire work FRAME BY FRAME, ZOOMING IN if necessary. No wires could be seen.
In a time before the spoiler ridden, egregious journalism of
AICN.COM, tired CGI lizards, overuse of 'Flo-motion' and other boring conventions of 90s
cinema, the Salkinds gave us Supergirl. This film was made as an addition to their damage
proof 80s pop culture product franchise, and this is where audiences were divided, because
the majority had come to see the man of steel. While Supergirl is no winner in terms of
narrative, as social practise it is incredibly interesting. Supergirl comes from her
Utopia environment and lands in the middle of Reagan's 1983, actually filmed in the new
romantic flavoured UK, taking great advantage of Thatcher's pound. Here, not unlike her
Utopian home town of Argo, the palace is inhabited by clean, sweater wearing, non drug
taking pretty boys and girls, who listen to the tunes of the then 28 year old god of
synthesised music, Howard Jones. Indeed at the Midvale high school, the only drunk on
campus is the janitor, and it is in this environment that Jimmy Olsen, who always looked
an out cast amongst the 30 somethings of the Daily Planet looks at home. Adding to the
contemporary fashions of neon, pinks and hot waxed hair is the Chicago setting, which at
the time was synonymous with teen flicks, most notably all of John Hughes films. The
greatest contrast to this is the Phantom Zone used later on in the film, a new romantics
nightmare, where colours are isolated and blood and grit darken the mood. Add to this Tony
Clarke's synthesised WHHOOOSSSHH sound FX, and then you'll realise that Supergirl just
COULDN'T be made outside of the mid- 1980s.
REVIEW by CrtmnCP
16th August
Very nicely
packaged DVD, the first disc illustrated with the red and yellow superman logo and the
second, special edition disc with the cinematic silver logo. The enclosed booklet is
rather interesting, providing brief details on the finding of the restored footage and
surprisingly a few negative criticisms about the film itself. It also contains a few
promotional materials made for the film's original release, mostly aimed at kids such as a
crossword puzzle and other things you would expect to find on a placemat at a McDonalds.
If this was the publicity for the film it is little surprise why it did so poorly at the
box office! The first disc is THX enhanced and is very well done. The storyboard extra is
a standout as you watch a series of storyboards one after another from a given sequence
accompanied by Jerry Goldsmith's score for that particular scene. The storyboards are
beautifully drawn as well and give you a glimpse at a few concepts that did not make it
into the film. Some storyboards are labelled Superman 3. Was this to be the next film
originally after Superman 2??? The Making Of documentary is pretty interesting since all
the actors involved participated including Peter O' Toole.
The second disc, containing the coveteded 140 min cut, is not in THX
sound. This is very disappointing but perhaps understandable from a budgetary standpoint.
They knew that the 140 min cut would only be seen by the 50,000 people who bought the
Special Edition and thus did not want to spend the funds to improve the sound for the lost
scenes. The lost scenes include the math class scene in Argo City, a confrontation with
Linda Lee and a classmate, and Nigel bidding farewell to Jimmy Olsen. Overall the expanded
scenes give the film a little more scope than the international version (previously
available on VHS and Japanese laserdisc) and is practically an epic compared to the
original US release.
Finally, this is a fun film and with the 140 min version in mind is
easily better than Superman 3 and 4, though it could never compare to the grandeur of
Superman 1 and the Donner segments of 2.
|